Prehistoric sculpin, a trouts delicacie in Vermonts Battenkill on a sweedish flat lure, they are small minnow size. I'VE caught water snake, in Croton Resvior lower NYS i caught small green snake that was after a sunny in a shallow underwater rock. Sheepshead that baa's when u rub his belly, long nose gar that will unthread ur net, plenty of snapping turtles even one on a white miller fly & painted box turtle on a grub jig. Bill Dance show he caught a sea sculpin (ugly) and stated it's one of best baits to use.

28 in. Tiger Musky in a small lake (7 acres) that was only suppposed to have bass, gills, and stocked trout.

yea i was fishing at a small stream catching bluegill. i hooked one and was pulling him up and the line got heavy all a sudden. i pulled up a 4 foot long copper head snake.

I caught a 8' Crappy and lost it too an 8' Gator, he won I broke the line off.

you know thats kinda funny cause i use to live in racine wi and a 9 year old boy caught a 8 inch pirannah in a man made pond it was in the paper and had pics to prove it and it was a red bellied pirannah like i had in my tank at home. i had the same thought winter should of killed it. but for myself ive caught seagulls in the tongue throwing shad, in mid air and on the water, a prostetic leg that was odd, a minnow bucket that still had live minnows in it, a muskrat, a snapping turtle that was bigger then a truck tire(wasnt gonna try getting it in the boat),last but not least i caught my buddy right in the ear lobe with a big ol musky bait, treble hook went strait through looked like some kind of punk rock earring. got him drunk and took it out. all sorts of clothes and garbage

my fav. I was drifting sand worms though a tidal current and caught 2 or 3 muscles the hook would get clamped in the shell like it was trying to bite it got a photo of it some place

72 inch lake sturgeon while dad and I were fishing for walleye. 3 1/2 hours before we got it in the boat.

I caught a tennis ball in Kent Lake, Michigan.
Tight Lines!!!

I don't know if this would count, but one day the garbage man came by and accidentally dumped some garbage in my ditch, which has water in it. I fished out a Coke can and inside it was a crawfish.

A pair of dirt old bloomers on a lake in Kansas. I think they were a size 44, for a very large woman.